Category Archives: Uncategorized

Civil society letter on NPPA’s action on price control

Shri Ananth Kumar
Hon’ble Minister of Chemicals and Fertilizers
Udyog Bhavan
New Delhi 11001
 
20 August 2014
 
Dear Ananthji,

 

The National Pharmaceuticals Pricing Authority (NPPA), on July 10, 2014, released a new set of price notifications for 50 cardiovascular and diabetes medicines under paragraph 19 of the Drug Prices Control Order (DPCO), 2013. The notifications for the 108 formulations (two were subsequently withdrawn) of these selected medicines are in addition to the notifications for essential medicines declared under the DPCO 2013. We note that the earlier notifications for essential medicines excluded several dosage forms and strengths because they did not feature in the National List of Essential Medicines (NLEM), 2011. Thus the recent notifications were necessary to cover more of the strengths of medicines than that are listed on the NLEM. In addition, the notifications also covered medicines in the cardiovascular and diabetes therapeutic categories that are not included in the NLEM.

We the undersigned civil society organizations welcome the initiative of the NPPA to cap the prices of formulations involving essential and lifesaving medicines that fall outside the NLEM as a first step towards the institution of a robust, pro-public health policy of drug price control. This is an action that truly interprets the spirit of the Drug Prices Control Order, and its underlying legislation the Essential Commodities Act, 1955. In the past, despite its attention being drawn to the profiteering in medicines not listed in the DPCO, the government had looked the other way.

We are surprised at the misinformation being spread by the Pharmaceutical Industry in this regard, and its efforts to prevent relief to the consumer by filing petitions in the high courts in Mumbai and Delhi. Industry has challenged the legality of fixing the prices of the 50 medicines under Paragraph 19 of the DPCO 2013 when in fact the Government has in successive drug price control orders always retained the power to intervene in prices in the public interest in the light of evidence of overpricing.

Limiting all price regulation only to a list of 348 medicines and specified dosages and strengths in the DPCO 2013 goes against the policy objective of making medicines affordable to the public. The National List of Essential Medicines, a list of 348 rational and cost-effective medicines, is not the basis for production, promotion and prescription in India. In reality the most frequently prescribed and consumed medicines are not listed in the NLEM.

Industry has claimed that this will cause an annual loss of revenues of over Rs.600 crores. NPPA’s action on the market will however be marginal, and nowhere near the doomsday predictions of the industry. It will affect only those brands that were selling at very high prices. We have analysed the impact of the notifications and found that the retail market of Rs.77,526 crores (Moving Annual Total, June 2014) would experience a loss of  Rs. 350 crores (AIOCD-AWACS, PharmaTrac Data, 2014).  This represents a loss of approximately only 2% (Rs. 112 crore) in the anti-diabetic therapy segment and 2.5% (Rs. 238 crore) in the cardiac therapy segment. This in a way establishes the excess profits of the industry in those particular formulations by overcharging the patients.

Also the market based price fixation being followed by the NPPA, a departure from the long used cost-based price control mechanism, is irrational and means that the ceiling prices are still very high. Many medicines are sold by reputed companies much below the NPPA ceiling price. The ceiling price of atorvastatin 40mg is Rs. 22.02 per tablet while Biochem Pharmaceutical is selling the same at a much lower price of Rs. 14.94 per tablet. The ceiling price of glimepiride 3mg is Rs. 10 per tablet, while Ipca Laboratories is able to sell it for Rs. 6.90 per tablet. As per our calculations only a little over one fourth of packs selling on the market will need to revise their prices downwards because they were originally priced higher than the notified price. This is evidence that there is a scope for significant reduction in NPPA ceiling prices, without affecting the reasonable profits of the industry.

We also note that the notifications have not included fixed dose combinations in the cardiovascular and diabetes therapeutic categories whereas the sales of many combinations exceed those of the single molecule medicines.

We also raise the argument that fixing of ceiling prices of all the other dosage forms of all medicines under NLEM cannot be neglected. Here again the same phenomenon of overcharging remains. NPPA should come out with similar action to cover all dosage forms and fixed dose combinations containing one or more medicines under NELM, and as well as bring other essential and life saving medicines under price control immediately.

Although this notification of NPPA will give some relief to patients in the chronic disease sector in the present context, it should be expanded and rationalized. We request the Government and NPPA to strongly defend its stand and also consider the actions suggested by us to promote public health.

Signed,

All India Drug Action Network (AIDAN)
Jan Swasthya Abhiyan
Low Cost Standard Therapeutics (LOCOST)
Medico Friends Circle
Third World Network- India
All India Peoples Science Network (AIPSN)
National Working Group on Patent Laws

 
Copy to:
Hon’ble Shri Narendra Modi, Prime Minister of India
Hon’ble Shri Dr. Harsh Vardhan, Minister of Health and Family Welfare
Mr. Nripendra Misra, Principal Secretary, Prime Minister’s Office
Mr. Lov Verma, Secretary, Department of Health & Family Welfare, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare
Ms. Aradhana Johri, Secretary, Department of Pharmaceuticals, Ministry of Chemicals & Fertilizers
Mr. Injeti Srinivas, Chairman, National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority, Department of Pharmaceuticals, Ministry of Chemicals & Fertilizers

 
 
 
For further information, contact:
 

LOCOST
1st Floor, Premanand Sahitya Bhavan
Dandia Bazaar
Vadodara, Gujarat – 390001
Ph: 9998771064
Email: chinusrinivasan.x@gmail.com

Jan Swasthya Abhiyan
National Secretariat
c/o Delhi Science Forum
D-158, Lower Ground Floor
Saket, New Delhi 110017
Ph: (011) 26524323, 26862716
Email: jsasect.delhi@gmail.com

 
 

Fresh plea filed against drug price control in SC by AIDAN & others

Image

Mumbai: Non-government organisations (NGOs) led by AIDAN (All India Drug Action Network) have filed a fresh application in the Supreme Court as part of their decade-long petition that had forced the government to bring all 348 essential drugs under price control. AIDAN, LOCOST, Medico Friend Circle and Jan Swasthya Sahyog together have filed a fresh intervention application in the Supreme Court, opposing the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Policy (NPPP 2012) and marketbased pricing mechanism to determine ceiling prices of drugs which are being brought under price control.

According to the fresh intervention application, the simple average formula to determine the ceiling prices (of drugs) actually increases their prices and… read more

Source: Times of India

Fresh plea filed against drug price control in SC

The EU says no to ACTA: to protect public health, other countries should also reject it

Posted by Leila Bodeux on Jul 12th, 2012 in Access to medicines | Global Health Check

The European Parliament (EP) made a landmark decision to reject the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA), by a majority of 478 votes out of 682.  The Agreement was negotiated between the EU, United States, Australia, Canada, Japan, Morocco, New Zealand, Singapore, and South Korea….. ACTA is dangerous because it is not strictly limited to countering trade in true “counterfeiting”, defined narrowly under the WTO TRIPS Agreement as the “deliberate, fraudulent use of a trademark in order to deceive consumers”. Instead, ACTA creates severe penalties in connection with a range of types of IP infringement and IPR disputes, most of which have nothing to do with counterfeiting. For instance,…. read more

Supreme Court Order in the AIDAN Drug Pricing PIL – Oct 11, 2011

1
ITEM NO.101 COURT NO.7 SECTION PIL
S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A
RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO(s). 423 OF 2003
ALL INDIA DRUG ACTION NETWORK AND ORS. Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. Respondent(s)

(With appln(s) for permission to submit additional
document(s),PERMISSION TO FILE ADDITIONAL AFFIDAVIT)
Date: 11/10/2011 This Petition was called on for hearing today.
CORAM :
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE G.S. SINGHVI
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDHANSU JYOTI MUKHOPADHAYA
For Petitioner(s) Mr. Colin Gonsalves, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Anuj Castleino, Adv.
Ms.Jyoti Mendiratta,Adv.(Not present)
For Respondent(s) Mr. T.S.Doabia, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Ashok Bhan, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Rekha Pandey, Adv.
Ms. Sadhana Sandhu, Adv.
Mr. R.K.Rathore, Adv.
Ms. Asha G. Nair, Adv.
Mr. Shalinder Saini, Adv.
Mr. P. Parmeswaran ,Adv(Not present)
Mr. D.S. Mahra ,Adv(Not present)
UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following O R D E R

At the commencement of hearing Shri Colin Gonsalves,
learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioners read
out portions of 45th Report of the Parliamentary Standing
Committee on Health and Family Welfare and 7th Report of the
2
Standing Committee on Chemicals and Fertilizers.
Thereafter, Shri Doabia, learned senior counsel appearing
for the Union of India placed before the Court a photostat copy of the Office Memorandum dated 20.06.2011 sent by the
Ministry of Health & Family Welfare to the Secretary,
Department of Pharmaceuticals on the issue of revision of
National List of Essential Medicines. Paragraph 2 of that
memorandum reads thus:
“2. In the above connection, it may be
stated that the National List of Essential
List (NLEM), 2003 has been revised. The
revised list, the NLEM, 2011 contains 348
drugs. While approving the list, the
Minister of Health & Family Welfare has also
approved that if affordable healthcare has
to become a reality, all the medicines
included in the NLEM, 2011 should be brought
within the ambit of price control under the
DPCO, considering the fact that the cost of
medicines in the overall cost of healthcare
constitutes more than 60% and a large
percentage of our people do not have access
to affordable healthcare. If, at all, such
medicines cannot be included under DPCO with
the same trade margins, there could be
graded system of trade/profit margins for
different categories and 348 medicines in
NLEM, 2011 could be so categorized. This
will ensure that reasonable margins and
growth of Pharma industry also do not get
adversely affected. The Minister has,
therefore, approved taking up the matter
with the Department of Pharmaceuticals for
further appropriate action.”
Shri Ashok Bhan, learned senior counsel appearing
for the Department of Chemicals and Fertilizers also placed
before the Court a xerox copy of Office Memorandum dated
04/05.10.2011. In para 6 thereof, it is mentioned that the
3
Department of Pharmaceuticals is examining all the
possibilities of control and monitoring of prices of
medicines including those covered under the NLEM, 2011.
Having perused the two Office Memorandums placed by
the learned senior counsel for Union of India and Department
of Chemicals and Fertilizers, we deem it proper to direct
the Secretaries of two Ministries to file their affidavits within four weeks indicating therein as to within what time
the revised list of National List of Essential Medicines
(NLEM) will be added in Schedule-I of the Drugs (Price
Control) order, 1995.
A comprehensive revised list of National List of
Essential Medicines (NLEM) be also produced along with
affidavit to be filed on behalf of the Ministry of Family &
Welfare.
List the case on 17.11.2011 for further hearing.
(Parveen Kr. Chawla) (Phoolan Wati Arora)
Court Master                Court Master

AIDAN Annual Meet 2012

The Annual Meet 2012 of the All India Drug action Network (AIDAN) will be held on Thursday, 5th January 2012 at Yatrinivas, Sevagram, Wardha from 10.30 am to 5.00 pm. This annual meet is being held in the context of the drug pricing PIL filed by AIDAN, which is being heard in the Supreme Court, and the draft National Pharmaceuticals Pricing Policy (NPPP-2011). At the international level, there is much happening on the IP, Innovation, Pharmaceuticals & Public Health front. We need to discuss these key issues and plan our action.

As usual, the AIDAN Meet is followed by the MFC meet. For those who are interested, you can get details on the MFC website: http://www.mfcindia.org

Kindly confirm your participation.

Contact persons:

1. Mira Shiva, (09810582028), mirashiva@gmail.com
2. Gopal Dabade (9448862270), drdabade@gmail.com
3. Srinivasan S. (Chinu), (08056292350), sahajbrc@gmail.com
4. Anant Phadke, (09423531478), anant.phadke@gmail.com
5. Naveen Thomas, (09342858056), navthom@gmail.com
6. Prasanna S. (09977216619), prasanna_aid@yahoo.com

On behalf of the AIDAN working group,
Naveen